Heisman Trophy candidate Ty Simpson University of Alabama quarterback is reviewed by MTB Scouting

Ty Simpson's Heisman Trophy Watch Performance: An In-Depth Analysis

As the college football season progresses, the spotlight intensifies on potential Heisman Trophy candidates. One such player is Ty Simpson, the quarterback for the University of Alabama. Recently, Simpson faced off against Oklahoma, a matchup that brought both high expectations and scrutiny. Despite a valiant effort, the game ended in a narrow 23-21 loss for Alabama, leaving fans and analysts alike questioning Simpson's candidacy for college football's most prestigious award.

Game Overview

In the game held on November 15, 2025, Simpson showcased a mixed performance. He completed 28 of 42 passes, achieving a completion percentage of 66.67%. He amassed 326 passing yards, contributing one touchdown through the air and one on the ground. However, he also recorded one interception and was sacked three times, which ultimately hampered his team's efforts in a critical game.

Statistical Breakdown

Simpson’s overall passer rating stood at 135.0, which, while respectable, does not fully encapsulate the nuances of his performance. Much of his passing yardage came from short completions, relying heavily on his receivers to generate additional yardage after the catch. This strategy highlighted a lack of deep passing effectiveness, as Simpson struggled with deep throws throughout the game.

The statistics also reveal an alarming trend: Simpson took eight rushing attempts but ended up with a net loss of nine rushing yards, indicating either poor decision-making in scrambles or a lack of effective blocking from his offensive line. The forced pass that led to his interception was a critical error, showcasing a moment of misjudgment under pressure.

Qualitative Assessment

From a qualitative standpoint, scouts noted that Simpson's performance was average across multiple attributes. His accuracy and arm strength were deemed average, and although he displayed reasonable anticipation and decision-making, inconsistencies plagued his game. For instance, he was often off-target, requiring his receivers to make extraordinary adjustments to secure catches.

Simpson's pocket presence has been characterized as adequate, with moments where he effectively navigated pressure. However, there were instances where he appeared unaware of impending hits, leading to a fumble that further derailed Alabama's momentum. His mobility was noted as above average, particularly when scrambling, yet this was not enough to elevate his overall game impact.

Impact on Heisman Stock

Following the game, Simpson's Heisman stock has been assessed as falling. The overall grade given to his performance was a C, indicating a below-average outing for a player in contention for the prestigious award. The media narrative surrounding his performance has shifted, reflecting disappointment given the high expectations set for a Heisman contender.

Despite his team's struggles, Simpson's supporting cast received mixed reviews. While the receivers were labeled average, the offensive line's inconsistent performance contributed to Simpson's difficulties, particularly in critical situations.

Conclusion

As the season progresses, Ty Simpson remains a player to watch, but his recent performance against Oklahoma raises questions about his readiness for the Heisman Trophy spotlight. The combination of statistical analysis and qualitative assessments suggests that while he possesses potential, significant improvements are necessary for him to reclaim his status as a serious contender. The road ahead will require not only personal growth but also enhanced team dynamics to elevate Alabama's performance and Simpson's candidacy in the eyes of Heisman voters.